Tuesday, March 23, 2010

A mani that just makes me grimace: OPI Creme de Menthe


I wanted this polish SO BAD. I don't have that many HTF lemmings but this is one polish that I just lusted after continuously. The only place I had seen it was eBay for a little less than $40 at Buy It Now. But after months and months and MONTHS of wanting this polish, I decided one night that, to hell with it, I want the polish and I've wanted it for about a year so I'm gonna get it and it's gonna be mine and I don't care what it costs!

So I encouraged eBay scalpers by paying nearly $40 for an old OPI. And now I'm regretting it. See, if it had cost $20, it might've been okay. But for $40 -- the most I've ever paid for a polish -- it had better be all that and a bag of chips. And it wasn't! Lesson learned: never overpay for an HTF again. :( It's not that I don't like this polish: it's simply not worth the amount of money I paid for it.

OPI Creme de Menthe


It's still a pretty polish. It's the color of a grasshopper cocktail with a healthy dose of gold shimmer. But it took four coats to get it to the above opacity... and there's still VNL. It applied sheerly, unevenly and... it feels frosty. I know it's weird to call a polish that doesn't have silver shimmer it "frosty" but it is kinda frosty. And I also hate my mani: the gap is larger than I usually like it to be. (I went a little overboard with the brush and acetone.) Looking at this post is making me cringe: a mani that I don't like with a color that I wasted my money on.


Like this? Click below to let us know!

14 comments:

jaljen said...

I sympathise, I really do.
I have found that the more I want it and the more I pay the more disappointed I generally am.
Classic case of over-promise and under-deliver. Expectations too high.
You could resell it on ebay and recoup some of your money. That's what I do when polishes don't wow me.....

Stephanie said...

Bummer :( But hey, if you really dislike it you can always toss it over my way ;)

Crystal said...

oh poor you....:( nothing worse than overspending....

but i still think it is a totally fabulous color...

NY*NAIL*DIVA said...

LOL @ STEPHANIE, TRY IT AGAIN IN A FEW DAYS, MAYBE IT WILL GROW ON YOU!

Chicky

said...

Aw that's such a shame! I love this colour and I've been lemming it for ages too. Maybe try layering it over another green?

Bunny Masseuse said...

I dunno, I'm digging... it's beautiful!

Michèle said...

Haha I so feel you, I have this on my wishlist too, but I'm holding back :'). However, I love this color on you, the shimmer is divine!

PolishPig said...

I bought this from e-bay too, not paying $40 but not cheap either.
I have not tried it yet but the beautiful bottle color makes it kind of worth owning anyway. Then again, I'm really a crazy hoarder..

mKat said...

So I have what is possibly a really dumb question (especially given the fact that I contribute to this blog) but how do you accomplish the gap at the cuticles (and why do you prefer it?) I guess that's two dumb questions.

I've never tried to do it, but I can see the benefit of not getting stuff all over your cuticles (though I'd get stuff all over my cuticles in the removal process anyway).

ShortAndSweetNails said...

Awww :(
I really love this polish and I wanted it for the longest time. I finally also got it off Ebay. I still love it though and am happy with it though IDK if I would be if I had paid $40!

Maybe if you layer it over something?!

Unknown said...

That sucks! But it is very pretty on your hands, maybe it can work for Stamping??

Arrianne said...

Yikes, 40 bucks. I couldn't imagine spending that much, especially for a not that great color. Sometimes I make my gap too big and it is frustrating. I like it on you though for some reason.

Lissi said...

WoW! And I thought $12.50 for Nfu-Oh or $18 for RBL was a lot. I'm sorry you weren't fully content with the price paid. I can only imagine how you feel. But it is a really nice green. I've liked that color for a while.

LizKS48 said...

I love it and if I had $40 to get it I would get it. I don't mind adding layers. :)

Related Posts with Thumbnails